Oh what joy to be able to post on this subject, vicarious satisfaction knows no bounds!
What sort of bike?
Road bike
You know what a road bike looks like so here is a Cannondale cross bike
Pros:
Light, sexy, fast, aesthetic advantage over all others
Cons:
Fragile, not greate on rough roads/tracks etc, a little impractical with shopping etc
Cross bike
Lemond cross bike
Pros:
Cool factor, disc brakes, practical and light
Cons:
Maybe expensive as in a niche
Hybrid
Trek Soho "fitness bike"
Pros:
Practical, comfortable and durable
Cons:
Geeky/nurdy, bit expensive as again a niche and not really a decision, but the result of failing to make a decision
Mountain bike
This is a Cannondale Urban bike, but it is just an MTB with slick tyres
Pros:
Good value, reasonably practical, disc brakes, cool (extra cool if you get a 29" wheel bike, but then more expensive), versatile. Could be good to get 2 sets of wheels - 700c and 26"
Cons:
Unoriginal, not good on the road, attractive to thieves
Conclusion
Yeah well, I dunno, probably best to get one of each!
But if you only want one, it depends on what you want to do, but I can't help thinking that a road bike is not what you want unless you plan to start riding more on the roads for fun rather than to get from A to B. Otherwise, go with the cross bike or find a cooler hybrid like Trek Soho
Of course you could buy this one, everyone will want it!
It is a Seven, but how about this Moots (from Steamboat Springs so supporting local business) old school touring bike, this is really nice and pretty suitable I would say.
That's it, drive to Steamboat Springs and get the guys to make you one of these, it will be ready by spring and I'm sure they'd do you one with disc brakes if that's what you want.